Skip to content

Industry Split on Data Centres’ Renewable Energy Solutions

“Giant loophole:” Industry divided over best – and cheapest – way to help data centres BYO renewables

Renewable energy firms and the lobby groups that represent them are united in seeking to harness soaring power demand from data centres but are divided on the treatment of generator credits derived from existing rather than new solar and wind farms.

These divisions centre on Renewable Energy Guarantee of Origin (REGO) certificates, with incumbents keen to maximise the value of such credits from operating plants. Critics say that approach could be seen as “green washing” that will do little to get new projects to financial close.

Among industry bodies, the Clean Energy Council (CEC) and the Clean Energy Investor Group (CEIG) are in effect pitted against the Smart Energy Council (SEC). Individual firms, too, cluster according to how much existing capacity they have versus ambitions to build new capacity.

“If we want to ensure the extra demand from data centres doesn’t increase emissions and doesn’t increase prices there’s only one way – extra new renewables supply,” said Tristan Edis, Green Energy Markets’s chief executive officer.

“We need to be extremely careful we don’t inadvertently create a giant loophole for data centres to escape a requirement to bring on new supply,” Edis told Renew Economy.

“Buying [large-scale generation certificates] or REGOs from existing renewable energy projects are dirt cheap and will remain so given the huge oversupply of these certificates.”

The mixed signals emerging from the sector come as the Albanese government and state counterparts work to marshal the potential productivity benefits of one of the few growth dynamos in the economy without straining the power grid and pushing up power prices.

Ministers such as Chris Bowen have insisted clean energy is prioritised, although Coalition-led Queensland and the Northern Territory and even Labor-led South Australia have indicated they expect coal and gas to play important roles in supplying power to meet the anticipated soaring demand.

For context, the 2026 Electricity Statement of Opportunities by the Australian Energy Market Operator – which itself is being updated because of the latest delay for the Snowy 2.0 pumped hydro project – forecast data centre power usage would increase seven-fold to about 34 terawatt-hours over the next decade.

Among the regulators, the Australian Energy Markets Commission (AEMC) has recommended that, as “a temporary arrangement, in the initial year(s)”, data centres may meet their obligations through purchasing renewable energy guarantees of origin (REGOs) from existing generators.”

Anna Collyer, AEMC chair, later told Renew Economy that advice was “only something that we put up for consideration.”

A temporary arrangement has the backing of the CEC and CEIG, which favour the use of generic, or “vintage” REGOs from existing projects to support data centres,” according to their submissions to a Senate committee examining the impacts of artificial intelligence and data centres.

Their case hinges in part on the likely time gap between how fast new data centres can be built, versus the longer time it typically takes to get new renewables commissioned.

The CEIG cited CEC data from 2017 showing the average time for wind, solar and large battery projects to go from financial close to commissioning as 30, 21 and 23 months, respectively. Data centres had an average build time of about a year, the CEIG said, adding such construction times may not accurately reflect recent new projects.

“For the bridging mechanism itself, CEIG supports a model requiring data centres to surrender/retire LGCs or REGOs that have been acquired from an existing renewable energy project (excluding below-baseline REGO generators), to fill the time gap until their contracted new, additional generation has been connected,” the group said.

Such an arrangement “has the advantage of providing existing assets with a boost, which can help investors recycle capital into new generation projects”, it said.

The CEIG said the use of existing REGOs “should be limited to a three- to five-year window, after which data centre demand must be met by long-term contracting from new, additional generation”.

The CEC, for its part, noted New South Wales has suggested a “glide path” of four years for the transition, with Ireland offering up to six years. “CEC members have expressed support for both these numbers, with a strong consensus that whatever is chosen, there should be a review after 2 years,” it said in its submission.

A spokesperson for the CEC – which counts one data centre developer, AirTrunk, among its members – said “new data centre demand should ultimately be matched by equivalent additional renewable electricity supply, with data centres committing to that new supply at or around the time they make their own final investment decision.”

“The way to minimise upward pressure on [wholesale power] prices is to minimise the period in which new data-centre demand arrives ahead of new supply,” the spokesperson said.

“The objective is therefore to crowd in additional renewable capacity as quickly as possible, limiting any short-term price pressure and adding supply over the much longer operating life of those assets,” he said.

The focus, the CEC spokesperson said, should not be on “setting an arbitrary number of years” but rather determining how long the period is between when a data centre commences operation and its contracted additional renewable supply comes online.

The SEC, though, wants data centres “to match 100% of their electricity use with new and additional renewable generation, verified through REGO certificates.”

This outcome should come while recognising power purchase agreements and contracts under the Electricity Services Entry Mechanism (ESEM), the new market architecture expected to be in place from 2030, it says. Firming up that supply should also be sourced from storage rather than gas.

The Green Energy Markets’ submission to the Senate inquiry also strongly opposed the use of existing REGOs.

“First, it accomplishes nothing as there is no benefit to increasing renewable energy or reducing greenhouse emissions,” it said.

“Purchasing REGO’s from 40-, 20-, or even 10-year old generators does not result in any new generation being incentivised, let alone constructed,” GEM said.

“Second, the cost of this ‘obligation’ will be trivial as the supply of generic REGOs far exceeds the demand,” it said. “Therefore, there would be no incentive for the data centre to reduce the timeframe of the ‘temporary arrangement.’”

“In fact, it could well be in the data centre’s financial interest to extend this inexpensive ‘temporary arrangement’ for many years, resulting in higher prices for consumers as the new generation to support the data centre is delayed.”

Among individual firms, Jean-Christophe Cheylus, Neoen’s Regional CEO Australia Pacific, said his company “strongly supports a market-based solution,” with REGOs the primary compliance and audit mechanism. It has about 6 gigawatts of renewables operating or under construction.

“New data centres should be allowed to meet obligations through REGOs sourced from existing wind, solar, and battery storage assets as they establish operations,” Cheylus said.

“Importantly, we believe new electricity demand, such as from data centres, should be incentivised to be located in parts of Australia where renewable energy generation is already constrained or under-utilised,” he said.

Rob Wheals, CEO of Squadron Energy – which has about 2 GW of clean energy operating or under construction – said use of “existing REGOs while new generation is developed is sensible, but this cannot become the permanent solution.”

“Ultimately, large new loads need to demonstrate additionality by helping bring new renewable generation and firming into the system,” Wheals told Renew Economy.

“Otherwise, we risk adding significant new demand without adding corresponding new supply, putting upward pressure on electricity prices for households and businesses,” he said.

“We need to make sure we are not weakening the investment signal for the renewable projects Australia needs.”

Green Energy Markets’s submission said that whatever market settings result from the inquiries, the starting point for the sector’s changes should be taken from March this year when the Albanese government released its policy expectations for the industry.

“In order to achieve the government’s goal of data centres not causing electricity prices to rise in a given jurisdiction due to data centre electricity demand, the [variable renewable energy] PPA should be with a Renewable Energy project, ideally in the same state,” Green Energy Markets said in its submission to the senate inquiry.

“[W]e consider the effective date of the requirement for data centres to write PPAs for new VRE should be no later than March 23, 2026, even though the data centre standards will not be legislated until early 2027,” it said.

“Projects achieving FID after March 23, 2026, have known what the government’s requirements were and should be obligated to comply with the government’s stated requirements,” it said.

Edis, GEM’s CEO, says the renewable energy industry has the ability to respond – provided the right incentives are in place and the higher end of data centre needs don’t eventuate.

“This is completely doable – the average amount of new wind and solar generation added to the grid over 2018 to 2026 was 5.6 TWh per year,” he said. “Meanwhile AEMO forecasts data centre demand growth to 2035 of 3TWh per year.”

To join more than 29,000 others and get the latest clean energy news delivered straight to your inbox, for free, click here to subscribe to our free daily newsletter.

To support independent media, and combat AI slop, you can click here to make a one off donation or become a regular supporter of Renew Economy.

Peter Hannam

Peter Hannam is a veteran journalist whose work spans almost four decades and includes stints outside Australia, including time in China, Japan, Singapore and Mongolia. He has lately reported extensively on energy, climate and environmental issues in Australia, and also worked for the federal Climate Change Authority as a special media advisor.

Share this:
Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email
Print