Skip to content

Zen Energy Fined $2.15 Million During Liquidation for Energy Efficiency Failures

Zen Energy cops fine while in liquidation, for failing to meet state retailer obligations on energy efficiency

The liquidators of Zen Energy have been dealt a fresh financial blow, after the failed renewable energy retailer was issued with a more than $2 million fine for failing to meet its obligations under Victoria’s energy efficiency scheme.

Victoria’s Essential Services Commission (ESC) said on Wednesday that Zen Energy was being fined $2.15 million for failing to meet its 2025 liability under the Victorian Energy Upgrades (VEU) program – a state-run scheme that supports households and businesses to invest in energy efficiency.

Businesses accredited under the VEU create energy efficiency certificates when they complete eligible upgrades like installing air conditioners or electric water heaters, and energy retailers in the state must acquire and surrender these certificates each year to meet energy efficiency obligations. 

The ESC says 32 two retailers met their obligations in 2025, surrendering 7.5 million energy efficiency certificates valued at a total $591 million and accounting for 99 per cent of total certificate surrenders required across all retailers for the year.

“Zen Energy Retail Pty Ltd was the only energy retailer that didn’t meet its 2025 liability, with a shortfall of 23,965 certificates,” the ESC said. “The commission issued a penalty to ZEN Energy for $2.15 million for not meeting its obligation. ZEN Energy has not paid the penalty and is in liquidation.”

Zen was established in South Australia in 2024, and was led at times by Ross Garnaut and then his son Anthony, and had carved a significant niche in the renewable retailing business, with major contracts with the state government and other entities.

The company collapsed into voluntary administration in early July, handing McGrathNicol Restructuring partners Rob Smith and Jason Preston the “urgent task” of determining how to “deliver the best possible outcome for all stakeholders.”

McGrathNichol told creditors in August that the failure was due to a high risk trading strategy – long on solar and ultimately short on battery storage – and warned secured creditors would get up to 10c in the dollar in the case of liquidation, or possibly nothing at all, while unsecured creditors would likely get nil.

Zebre, the joint venture between Taiwan company HD Renewables and Zen, was successfully hived off, with Zen’s interest sold to investors just before the retail entity entered voluntary administration.

The fine from the ESC demonstrates the extent to which Zen Energy’s retail issues had been piling up, including network company SA Power Networks seeking a wind up order in the federal court over missed payments.

As Renew Economy has reported, Zen directors have blamed the fact that the business model exposed it to significant market risk through long-term and substantial positions in the energy market, with market conditions moving against these positions over the last two financial years.

They also pointed to long and unhedged LGC positions, and the fact that Zen paid more than the prevailing market rate to secure the energy products and contracts it needed to operate. These products and contracts included PPAs, battery tolling rights and wholesale contracts.

The administrators also blamed Zen’s long solar generation position, that meant it was selling electricity at a loss, delays to storage assets coming online that could have protected short positions in the evening peaks, and “potential failings in good corporate governance and risk management practices.”

It said this meant that the business did not sufficiently manage downside risk in establishing the long term business model.

As at early August, Administrators said senior noteholders’ claims were approximately $177.8 million, with a further $15 million from super senior noteholders. Trade debtors were put at $27 million, $8 million was owing to staff and up to $347 million in unsecured creditors.

The relatively small ESC fine no doubt sits at the bottom of the list.

Renew Economy has sought an update on the liquidation process from Zen Energy administrators at McGrathNicol.

If you would like to join more than 29,000 others and get the latest clean energy news delivered straight to your inbox, for free, you can click here to subscribe to our free daily newsletter.

Sophie Vorrath

Sophie is editor of Renew Economy and editor of its sister site, One Step Off The Grid . She is the co-host of the Solar Insiders Podcast. Sophie has been writing about clean energy for more than a decade.

Share this:
Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email
Print